Skip to Content
FirmBuilders
FILTERS
  • Built to Last: A Wake-Up Call for First Generation Law Firms
    11/17/2026
     

    The news from Weil surely sent a shiver down the spines of partners who assume their firms will always be there.

    Last month, it was reported that Weil, Gotshal & Manges’s management committee had recommended an orderly wind-down. The proposal, which was to go to a partnership vote, was a sobering development for a nearly century-old firm known for helping others through financial distress.

    What does this mean for the legal profession and the business of practicing law? Weil’s circumstances are its own, but its predicament raises a question for the management of Big Law firms as well as the founders of much smaller firms: How sound is the institution behind the name on the door?

    Weil is a very different institution from the 50- to 150-lawyer firms that occupy prestigious offices along Park Avenue, Madison Avenue, and Avenue of the Americas. A prestigious name, impressive offices, and marquee clients can make a firm feel unsinkable. Think Titanic. The ship may still be moving, but that is no reason to ignore the iceberg ahead.

    Entrepreneurial lawyers who left larger firms to establish their own practices founded many of these smaller firms in the 1980s and 1990s. Call them “Boomer Firms,” shorthand for that founding generation. They built respected firms, impressive client rosters, and substantial businesses. From the outside, these firms look successful. Many still are. Others may be surviving on fumes without recognizing how little is holding the business together. A successful law practice is not necessarily a sustainable one.

    The name is still on the door. The founders are still practicing or slowly winding down. Lawyers are doing the work. But productive partners are leaving, the associate ranks are shrinking, the firm has deferred investments, and client relationships remain concentrated in a few senior hands. The firm keeps operating, drawing on what its founders built, without replenishing what it will need to continue.
     

    A Band Aid Will Not Stop a Hemorrhage

    Law firms have asked me to help recruit partners and associates, develop business development programs, coach lawyers, and identify merger candidates. Some hoped to enhance their brand and turn service partners into rainmakers, almost as if those changes could happen by magic and would right struggling ships. The more the conversations turned to the condition of the business, the more apparent it became that the proposed solution might leave the underlying problems untouched. Was the institution itself sufficiently sound to benefit from it?

    Find a rainmaker. Bring in a practice group. Train the lawyers to develop business. Find a merger partner.

    A Band-Aid will not stop a hemorrhage.

    A lateral hire, acquisition of a group, a business development seminar, or a new website may address an immediate need. But none can substitute for repairing fundamental structural and process weaknesses in the business. The danger is that the partners become accustomed to treating the symptoms while the underlying problems grow.

    A merger may eventually make sense. It can also add costs, obligations, and personnel issues to a business whose underlying problems remain unresolved. A new rainmaker needs lawyers, systems, and support to deliver the work. Training accomplishes little if the firm provides no time, budget, or reward for applying it. An expedient solution can consume scarce money and time without making the business stronger.

    As founders approach retirement, the conversation naturally turns to succession. But the condition of the business matters right now to partners, associates, staff, and clients. Waiting for a founder’s retirement or a major rainmaker’s departure to examine it may mean waiting for a crisis.
     

    Not the Firm You Need Today

    When the founders started these Boomer Firms, they managed the business through less formal systems for finance, training, business development, and client service. They often made decisions one by one, not needing an overall strategic plan. The founders knew the clients, knew the lawyers, and could work through problems as they arose.

    Client expectations and loyalty, competition, technology, the economics of practicing law, and the aspirations of younger lawyers have changed dramatically. The relationships, reputation, and entrepreneurial instincts that built a successful firm may no longer be enough to sustain it.

    Decisions about the business are now more closely connected. Adopting AI affects training, staffing, pricing, supervision, and client service. Its usefulness depends on the work, the support systems, and the people responsible for using it. Buying a tool does not settle any of those questions.

    A new rainmaker affects compensation, staffing, training, and the capacity to serve clients. Cutting expenses may protect current distributions while weakening the support needed to retain lawyers and clients. You can improve this year’s results by deferring investment, but you risk leaving the next owners with a business that costs considerably more to operate than they expected.

    This cannot be a game of Jenga, moving one piece at a time and hoping the structure holds.

    Strategic decisions need to be made in concert with one another. Weak collections can limit investment in talent and technology; inadequate support can drive lawyers and staff away and put client relationships at risk. Addressing one problem without understanding its effect elsewhere may simply move the pressure to another part of the firm.

    The question is not whether the founders built a successful business. Clearly, they did. Is the institution capable of succeeding without them and under very different business circumstances?
     

    Writing on the Wall

    The warning signs are often there long before a firm acknowledges that it has a problem.

    Departing talent. Productive partners are leaving with clients, institutional knowledge, and perhaps the next generation of leadership. Associate ranks are shrinking. and it is increasingly difficult to find quality replacements. Younger lawyers may see limited opportunities, or the firm may have stopped investing in the talent it will need tomorrow.

    Unsupported business development. Firms have invested in training partners and associates, encouraged them to create individual business development plans, and then failed to provide the budgets, resources, or support to execute them. Firms tell partners to go to networking events elsewhere but provide no travel budget to support those opportunities. They do not reward those who have mastered new skills and are applying them. Firms expect others to develop business without much help from the rainmakers who know how to do it.

    Inadequate financial information. The finance team cannot prepare a reliable budget, reconcile information, or explain where the firm makes and loses money. Producing reports is not the same as having the information needed to make decisions.

    Concentrated authority. The same equity partners make the important decisions one by one without an agreed strategic plan, clear accountability, or meaningful participation by those who will inherit the consequences.

    Cybersecurity and operational vulnerability. Inadequate infrastructure, weak cybersecurity, or an inability to recover quickly from a serious disruption can expose years of deferred investment. A firm that cannot protect client information or restore operations puts both its work and its relationships at risk.

    Client concentration and succession risk. A few clients or senior partners account for a disproportionate share of revenue. What happens when a key client leaves or a relationship partner retires? Younger partners need introductions and real responsibility for developing those relationships before a transition becomes urgent. A firm needs to prioritize that “handoff” process long before key players retire or disappear.

    Individually, these problems deserve attention. Together, they suggest that a firm’s ability to sustain itself may be slipping away even while current results look reassuring.
     

    Fresh Eyes on the Firm

    Before choosing what will save the firm, understand what needs fixing. Bring in experienced, independent advisers to examine the institution rather than carry out the founders’ preferred solution. The work may require expertise in finance, law firm management, compensation, technology and cybersecurity, recruiting, business development, and organizational strategy. No single consultant necessarily possesses all these capabilities.

    Assemble the expertise the firm needs and require the advisers to develop an integrated assessment. Start with the dependencies that put the firm’s future at risk: clients tied to departing founders, concentrated leadership, retirement obligations, deferred investment, and younger partners’ willingness to become owners. Examine the numbers alongside the people, practices, technology, and client relationships they support.

    Understand contribution as well as cost. This is not simply a ranking by billable hours. A partner may be developing a practice or doing necessary management work that the numbers fail to recognize. A busy practice may tie up lawyers on work the firm regularly writes off or struggles to collect.

    An outside perspective can help because some subjects are difficult to discuss among partners who have worked together for decades. An expense, a compensation arrangement, or an underperforming practice may have gone unquestioned for years. Advisers must be independent enough to challenge those arrangements, even when changing them would be uncomfortable for the founders.

    Identify what needs attention now, what can wait, and what the firm can afford. Put costs and dependencies together, assign responsibility, and agree on how to measure progress. Separate projects will fail if each assumes resources the others also require.
     

    Bring the Next Owners In

    Involve the next generation of leaders, particularly those who have or will have equity stakes. They will be responsible for the investments and will live with the decisions. Let them help plan their future. That means giving them access to information and involving them while the firm develops its options. Seek input from associates, staff, and clients about how the firm actually works.

    Prospective owners may question the price, retirement obligations, deferred investments, or the authority they will have. Those are reasonable concerns to resolve before expecting a commitment. Why would a younger partner invest, and what exactly would that partner be buying?

    Think of it as preparing a prospectus for the next owners. Account for assets and liabilities. Explain how the firm makes money, where the firm needs to invest, and which obligations carry forward. Lay out the plans and identify the leadership. Give prospective owners enough information to assess the business and a meaningful say in its future.
     

    Still Choices to Make

    Once the firm understands where it stands, it can make informed choices. A whole-firm merger is one route. Bringing in a practice group, acquiring a smaller firm, or recruiting individual lawyers may be more appropriate. Each requires sound economics and a plan to integrate the people and their work.

    Growth is not the only option. Developing the firm’s own people, spinning off a practice, helping a group move to another firm, reducing overhead, or downsizing may leave a stronger business. In some cases, an orderly transition or wind-down may be the responsible course.

    Each choice has consequences for clients, lawyers, staff, and the obligations of the partnership. The question is which course the partners are willing and able to carry out. Continuing to operate as though nothing has changed is itself a decision and perhaps the riskiest one of all.

    The founders deserve credit for what they built. They took risks, brought in clients, and created opportunities for others. But a capable successor cannot indefinitely overcome unreliable financial information, deferred investment, uncertain client relationships, and ownership terms that prospective partners do not understand or accept.

    Before asking who will take over, establish what you are handing over. The time to examine the business is while the firm still has the people, relationships, and resources to change it.

    A solid foundation, strong walls, and no holes in the roof. A business capable of thriving long after its founders have stepped aside. Something sustainable. Something worth inheriting.


    Andrea K. Stimmel is the founder of P2B FirmBuilders which provides strategic marketing, business development, communications, and growth leadership to law firms and professional services organizations. This article grew out of meetings and her work with Boomer law firms. "Reprinted with permission from the November 16, 2026 issue of the New York Law Journal. © New York Law Journal ALM Global Properties LLC, trading as Centellic. Further duplication without permission is prohibited contact 877-256-2472 or asset-and-logo-licensing@alm.com. All rights reserved."